Navigation

Poison the Well “Versions” CD

Poison the Well - Versions"Versions" is the latest from Poison the Well (and their Ferret Music debut), and all l can say is that there are a lot of hilariously inaccurate "reviews" of this album floating around out there. I mean, shit, based on a lot of what I had read prior to hearing it for myself I was almost afraid to listen to the damn thing because people were practically making it out to be some kind of fucking country record or something, which is absolutely laughable. Is it better than their last album? Hell yes. I don't think I've listened to that thing since the week I bought it, and I might not even have it anymore. Is it more diverse than their earlier material? Does it represent a continued growth? Absolutely, yes, of course. But just because mandolin, banjo, synthesizers, and Wurlitzer piano are credited in the booklet, that doesn't make this a "country" sounding album on any level—nor do the occasional appearances of jangly slide guitar textures or things like that. There's still plenty of screaming, lots of caustic guitar work, and a good dose of frenetic speeds. But yeah, there's also singing and spoken passages, weird little rocked out riffs, darker and more atmospheric passages, some pretty intense melodic undercurrents, etc. Plus, loads of recording techniques are employed to keep things from always sounding the same, though all things considered the album is also surprisingly cohesive. But everything's always warm and spacious, and that's fuckin' great. And layering. Tons of layering—the fact that they basically wrote and recorded this shit as a trio is pretty damn impressive, even if the music's not particularly your thing. You can't pigeonhole it, though. As opposed to "metalcore" (which this really is not), on some level it's kind of like an AmRep noise rock take on Converge with an indie-twist or something like that. And I don't want the Converge mention to discredit Poison the Well in any way, because it's just a loose reference point within the bigger picture, they're not operating in that realm, they're doing their own thing here. My point is just that, while boundaries are pushed—and diversity and creativity welcomed with open arms—this is not some "alien" sounding album that's going to drop jaws to the floor, you know? I've never been a huge Poison the Well fan, but I have owned all of their albums at one point or another (and still have most of 'em), and they've come a hell of along way since the early days. For my money this is their best album, too (handsomely packaged in a slick digipack with some really nice looking artwork, I might add)... just give it a chance and don't buy into all the inaccurate bullshit hype that's out there. Whatever the hell you want to call it, there are actually some pretty damn killer moments herein.

Poison the Well "You Will Not Be Welcomed"
Poison the Well "Letter Thing"

You know the drill. Like it? Then buy it:

Ferret Music
The End Records
Very Distribution

Comments

  1. You’re right about a lot of people making this out to be a country record. I do love this album. It’s an achievement for the band and I hope more metalcore bands decide to follow suit with expanding their sound and do something than thinking writing breakdown after breakdown constitutes a song.

    5.25.2007 | By Eddie

  2. All the sudden it’s cool to be a hillbilly in hardcore again.  It’s like Urban (Disciplne) Cowboy.

    5.25.2007 | By Johnny

  3. “All the sudden it’s cool to be a hillbilly in hardcore again.” hmmm you’re gonna have to name a few more (“hardcore”) bands that are tearing up banjos for me to believe that. (Not that you’re wrong or anything but I just havent heard of too many, ‘tis all.) But, anyways, I was severely disappointed with You Come Before You. So I’ve been a bit apprehensive about buying this new one. I have to agree with Eddie on the whole bands playing an entire breakdown for three minutes and calling it a song deal. Can’t stand it either. However,  I feel like, had PTW added atleast a few, if not a couple hardhitting breakdowns in YCBY; I would have enjoyed it more. Especially since I really dug a lot of the blues’ish riffs and what not. Every time I thought a breakdown would come they’d take it to an extremely melodic place.(Which isn’t bad, at first.) But then, thats all they went to for the entire cd. It’s like instead of oversaturating their music with monotonous breakdowns they replaced them with clean melodic passages(even when I REALLY wanted to hear a breakdown or something hard) . So, I ended up getting bored of it. (I’m not asking for relentless pummeling maddness or anything I just want them to bring the pain (so to speak) every once and awhile, ya know? Well, obviously you can tell I’m a long time fan of these guys so I just hope this cd is indeed an improvement. Ok, done venting.

    5.25.2007 | By Adrianoso

  4. Adrianoso, did you listen to these two tracks?  Curious what you thought based on your comment.

    5.25.2007 | By Andrew Aversionline

  5. Yeah, man as far as the Hillbilly Hardcore thing, you got bands like Bastard Saint or the Doomriders getting their long haired blues on, but with younger bands, like especially here down South, it’s mega popular to say you’re influenced by “Southern Rock” and kick around with an inferior college softmore beard and Ronnie Van Zant wannabe wardrobe.  Check any presser from a band these days.

    For specifics, I would cite something like this:  Remove the Veil garbage on Facedown as very typical of the trend.  For everyone of these signed bands, there are 20-30 more local ones kicking around.  Although it seems to be a generational, cross genre thing, it seems most prevelent in the goofy Jesuscore crowd that exists here in the South.

    5.25.2007 | By Johnny

  6. Actually, I haven’t. I’m at work right now and this computer is basically an electronic typewriter with no soundcard lol. I’ll have to wait till after 5 (pacific time) when I get home. I asked my co-worker if he had heard it and he told me that he had cuz his lil sis bought it (she’s cool like that) and he just gave me one of those, “eh” with a shaky hand gesture. So, guess I’m just gonna have to be patient till.

    5.25.2007 | By Adrianoso

  7. Johnny: Thanks for the info dude. I’ll check it out. Although, I think I might just stay away from them Jesus-freak bands. Not that I don’t like Jesus, its just I’m not too fond of having him shoved down my throat with helpful handfulls of hardcore, tu sabes?

    5.25.2007 | By Adrianoso

  8. Adrianoso, I definitely agree w/you about the J-core.  It’s just with being in the tat biz down here and around the undergound music thing, it’s hard to avoid those kids at times and whatever trend their doing, which hopefully involves me making money, haha.  I do often ask them what the benefit of converting somebody maleable enough to have their religious beliefs determined by a punk rock record, but I rarely get a decent answer.

    5.25.2007 | By Johnny

  9. I must say, that even though I haven’t been a huge Poison the Well fan in a long, long time, this is actually an enjoyable record. I’ve found that I’m slowly turning into one of those guys who keeps saying a band’s first record was their best one, but Poison the Well do keep impressing me by pulling off all these changes so well.

    5.25.2007 | By xGabrielx

  10. Gabe, i’m also one of those guys (the demo was the shit man!), and i’ve fallen in and out of love with Poison The Well, but there’s no denying that this is a solid album.

    And it’s true. Most bands do peak at with the material written under the least amount of pressure; the demo and the debut album.

    5.26.2007 | By Mike

  11. “the fact that they basically wrote and recorded this shit as a trio is pretty damn impressive” is exactly what I’ve thought ever since I got the album. Very well executed, and one of my favourites by the band.

    & has anyone else noticed the sort of quiet trend these previously (more-or-less) metal/hardcore/combinations-thereof bands all of a sudden turning around and writing albums more experimental in nature, and far less true to their “metal/[post-]hardcore/combinations-thereof” roots?
    Look at the new albums from Poison the Well, Fear Before the March of Flames, the Locust…
    I hope it continues, as all of these albums have been a refreshing change of pace.

    5.26.2007 | By Calvin

  12. Ok. So I listened to both tracks. And I wasn’t really sure what to think of “You Are Not Welcomed.” It still had that YCBY feel so I was kinda wishy washy on how I felt. But then I heard “Letter Thing” and now I just GOTTA hear the rest of the cd. (That sliding e!guitar riff fuckin GOT me!) In agreance with Calvin; I too like the idea of bands reaching out and experimenting.  Between the Buried and Me is another band that has evolved with each subsequent release and they have just completely surpassed my every expectation. I can honestly listen to their entire discography from their first cd to their latest without having to change to a different track, Ever. (Yes, even their cover cd, I own them all!)....So in conclusion, I think Versions just might revive my interest in PTW. (oh and I like the cover art, as well heh.) ((FUCK! That sliding guitar riff was badass!))

    5.27.2007 | By Adrianoso

  13. There’s been lots of mixed review that’s fo sure. I think it’s little over the top to say Versions is the new Shape Of Punk To Come… and so on, heh even they had the guys who recorded Shape… in helm. I really disliked Versions first, but with few listens it grew to status of “ok” record, so it’s not that bad or not that “country” of “southern rock” as i though it could be. Even i’m not into those influences that much it’s at least intresting influence. Only PTW record i still have is Opposite Of December Lp and it’s really the only PTW record i listen from time to time, i had all of ‘em, but they just weren’t so great on material. Versions has some pretty intresting shit on it, but still i consider it not to be the “Shape Of Punk (or Hardcore) To Come”.

    5.27.2007 | By xmarkusx KTL

  14. they’ve sure come a long way since tracks like “nerdy”, which i absolutely abhor. i dig this new “dirtier”, indie-ish take on things. and as for the country “twang” - i’m not picking up any. sounds like AmRep to me. still not the most engaging or moving listen in the world, but the band has sure matured. good shit.

    5.28.2007 | By chris

  15. LOL, thats really funny about the reference to remove the veil. my band just played a show in Mississippi with them, and they were pretty awful. The south is covered with the southern metal, hillbilly hardcore, whatever you want to call it, its there. Ever since maylene and the sons of disaster, it has just exploded. BUT, I do think there is a great field for expansion in that general area, for example with the indie band, Hot Rod Circuit and their latest album “The Underground Is A Dying Breed” that Andrew reviewed a month or so ago.

    For me, this album thew me with some of the smoother guitar playing in harder parts of the song. Maybe I am just delusional, but I hear that type of playing that just sticks out like a sore thumb. I guess I am just not used to it, cause a lot of other people seem to dig it. I am just glad they made a move from that last album in the right direction….

    5.28.2007 | By Steve Z

  16. not impressed by you come before you ay!? i rated that cd quite very highly. much better than the 1st 2 full lengths. i never understood the hype prior to YCBY (Still not sure i do… have never made it all the way thru “tear from the red” in one sitting)
    As such i was hoping for something along the same lines as YCBY especially as it was produced by the same two guys.
    on initial listens i was pretty bummed, but i think part of that was the production, which is nothing like on YCBY (versions is much tinnier to these ears). i’m still not a fan of the production, but these songs subtly bury their way into your brain. the wall of noise created is amazing in the way it can be so catchy and warrant repeated listening.
    lately, i have lamented the fact that the music scene is saturated with so much pablum these days. it’s getting rare that i get really moved by a record. maybe i’m just getting old. but this one has got me excited and then some.
    was a big fan of the band after the last cd and am an even bigger one now.

    5.29.2007 | By alexwank

  17. poison the well is one of the only bands i know that literally gets better and better with every album they release. well, them and converge, of course. versions is a fucking masterpiece and isnt even in the same league as the albums prior to it.

    7.23.2007 | By nelson